I've had this pencil for a long time now and finally decided to replace it recently with another brand. First off, it's not as dark of a black as I'd prefer. Then it smudges and wears off my waterline...

This is easy to apply, goes on dark, and doesn't smudge. However, it fades throughout the day.

This is the first eyeliner I have ever used in my life. This was back in 2001 i think and I still use it to give me a nice smolder. Since then, I've ventured off into gel, cream and liquid liners. I'v...

Works great for me; goes on smoothly and doesn't irritate

Well, yes, it may smear a little at th end of the day. But I really like that the color is SO black and the pencil is so creamy, which makes it so easy to apply.

I've yet to find a better pencil eyeliner. The deep dark black colour that's easy to apply (not skippy or scratchy), stays put all day and never breaks when sharpened - HG! I use this every day and hi...

I have this and threw it out because it frustrated me! The packaging is nice with the smudger tip at the end, but I can buy my own smudger for the cost of this pencil! This runs really bad - so it m...

I have this in Kohlberry 01, a black color. I really like the creamy feel of the pencil. The color stays pretty well, and it's pretty easy to smooth out while applying even for someone like me, a ne...

I had previously decided that eyeliner simply wasn't for me, before I tried this kohl eye pencil. Now I'm an eyeliner junkie. I'm in love with this pencil's consistency, although touch-ups are a MUST....

This is a cool liquid liner tough to get the hang of but when u do oooH Honey MAGIC!*+* it works with all colors and looks.