I can't believe how bad this stuff is. I expected a quite creamy consistency but this stuff was so dry I could barely pick any up in my brush. I tried a silicone brush and still no joy. It just clumpe...

I had been wanting to try a brown liner and when I saw this on sale for $5 I just had to buy it. The shade is a dark brown with cool tones and worked well with my neutral to cool fair skin. This is ...

This is a really dark brown. It looks almost black, but softer. I do like the color. I read the dry/creamy debate below, and to me it's both. It picks up on your brush easily, but it does have a thick...

PROS -This is the perfect shade of brown liner in my opinion. From a distance it may appear black on the eyes, but it's really quite a bit softer, yet still noticeable. I would describe the shade as a...

I really liked the look of this but was a bit reluctant to try it as I had read that it is dry and there were complaint of it not being creamy enough. However, I really liked the look of it in the st...

Love it. Applies like a dream. The prefect color, not harsh, like black can be. Yet dark enough that it's very noticable. I can control the intensity of color and the thickness of the line. I can e...

I love this as a gel liner! I use this with an eye liner brush I have from Ulta. I have used both MAC and Bobbi Brown gel liner, but I like this better. The consistency is good and this product doe...

I don't know if it was because I bought this and it was already dried out, but every time I use this, the cream clumps up. I have a lot of trouble with this getting in my eyes and irritating my allerg...

I've tried cheap and expensive gel eyeliners both. Mostly I've had a really hard time with the liner smudging and being hard to apply. I have to say that this is the best I've probably used. It does t...

My first purchase of this Smudge Pot was wonderful......I looooooved how it applied, very smooth and the staying power was amazing no smearing or fading....who knew. I didn't have any problems with i...