I wonder why this eyeliner has such a low rating?! I have this gel-crayon in NYMPH which is a blackened purple/violet and it is simply perfect for tightlining - no smearing on contact lenses, no smudg...

It's so difficult to put on. Lots of gaps. No playtime. It's really the worst eyeliner I've ever tried. I wouldn't repurchase if it was 1 dollar.

When the pencil is sharp I love this eyeliner! I’ve tried several different sharpeners and have ruined two pencils trying to sharpen them. When I do get a small tip It falls off. I am positive the ...

Good pigment but it smeared everywhere and ended up messy looking

I have Brewed which is a very richly pigmented cool toned dark brown eye pencil. Goes on without tagging, sets fast and stays put. Looks intense on the waterline too but as everything it does fade the...

This gel eyeliner is very, VERY pigmented. It is one of the richest, matte blacks I've ever used, particularly for a pencil. It is a gel eyeliner, and you are required to sharpen it. Every point of...

I have this in Fishnet (black) and I'm pretty impressed with it. It goes on super smoothly so I can easily get a clean, sharp line but it stays creamy for a few seconds so I can smudge it out a bit i...

I loved Smashbox products until I bought this liner. The color is perfect, but You cannot sharpen it. I tried everything, even my mounted regular pencil sharpener. So the money I spent on it, is wor...