I love the smoky eye look so I thought this would be a good bet but it was too waxy and crayon-like and not smudgy enough. Others have complained about it smudging but I say it doesn't smudge enough!...

Overrated, bad quality smudges very fast. Flakes after sharpening bad quality wood used. and most of all expensive for the poor quality it has

A good black khol pencil. I am referring to #61. Wears very well on the water line without sliding off. It is regular black, not jet black, like MAC Smolder, so if you are trying to achieve a more dra...

I was really dissapointed by the performance of this eyeliner from Chanel. the positive point of this eyeliner is that he color was actually a nice intense black and the texture glides easily and th...

Love love love! I'm on my second one of these & each one lasts me about 9 months with generous use from Monday to Saturday. I love this for the intense black line I get from several layers & its stayi...

I actually did not like this product at all! I gave the overall rating a 2 because its one of the few eyeliners that actually goes on my waterline! It has a nice black color but it doesnt stay! This e...

One of the best. I LOVE LOVE LOVE this eyeliner. It goes on well. Comes with a lot of product and a sharpener which is a plus. Some people may complain about the price but I think its worth it. Only r...

I've been using this eyeliner for the past 3 years non stop. It comes with a sharpener, which comes in very handy. This eyeliner goes on extremely smoothly, and it's very pigmented and black. It goes ...

For $28, I expect this eyeliner to be a godsend. This goes on smoothly and is nicely pigmented black (although not carbon super duper jet black). The pencil is not hard nor super creamy, but product ...

My HG eyeliner! The only eyeliner I like almost as much is the one Urban Decay makes. This just has a really nice consistency and stays on pretty well compared to most. I love that it comes with a sha...