My go to for the blackest of black eyeliners from MAC. I love smoulder eyeliner but it smudges on me during the summer. I sought out feline from MAC and was impressed with the payoff. You can wear it...

So, I went to MAC specifically asking for a black pencil liner which would be soft as possible to smudge for smokey eyes and the SA suggested Feline. For me and the purpose I need it for it's perfecti...

I really love this eyeliner pencil. over the years I have stopped using pencil on my lids, I use liquid liner there, but pencil works best for the lower lash line and waterline. I heard this pencil ...

2017 update: Still loving this - still Holy Grail! I do alternate this with YSL waterproof pencil (when I need that) and often combine it with kohl powder (I love smudgey smokey eyes!!!) but this is...

why oh whhyyy didnt i listen to the reviews. No lie...i put this on at 7am by 11am this liner migrated to my damn face. PISSED bare in mind i guess i have a moist waterline and i didn't set it with a...

I used smolder for the longest and it would smudge down my water line. When i ran out, i decided to try feline and it is better by far. It's super black and stays put on my water line all day. Well wo...

I have such a love-hate relationship with this product. I love how black it is, probably the richest black colored eyeliner i've ever tried. However, it smudges like CRAZY. I don't have oily eyelids a...

Okay, this is expensive -- I paid $30. And occasionally the lead breaks, upsettingly wasteful. BUT it is such a black black. Used inside (top and bottom) and outside (top only, smudged with smudge ...

Love Love Love this! I use it to tightline, close my eyes and it puts a little on my waterline so I like what it does. Will repurchase.

although i bought this in a limited edition collection, this eye pencil smudge on me after couple of hours. it doesnt have a stayin power and i end up looking with a raccoon eyes! i have oily lids and...