to me, it's just 'mehh"... the texture is kind of dry and cakey, which makes me wonder if i got an old one (i bought this during stila's online warehouse sale a couple months back for about $10). it ...

This was bought for me as a present - absolutely perfect as I love purple and gel liners. I love this colour but using it is not so great, I really do wonder if a 'smudge pot' really is a 'gel liner'...

My HG is Bobbi Brown gel eyeliners but I wanted to try out these Stila Smudgepots. Maybe I made a bad choice, they had SP LE shimmer liners at the store but I didn't know they were better than these o...

I have a collection of fluidlines and after hearing raves about Stila Smudge Pot, I have decided to give it a go. I picked Plum because I love purple and i know its the color i will wear all the time....

I honestly think there is nowhere near enough love for this product. I have purchased this several times over. I use it professionally as well as personally. I adore this rich, well pigmented gel l...

Best Eyeliner! Smudges Very Nicely! Mixed with Gray, it's the best for Brown eyes. I'd totally repurchase.

eh..my first stila smudgepot was black.. i loved it so much.. then gradually i got the other colors.. brown was good. nacy was ehh.. but when i got plum from sephora.. i hated it already on the first ...

if you think smudge pot is ace, i bet you didn't try MAC fluidline nor Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner. The texture of smudge pot is frustrating, cakey and dry, if you want a smooth line, smudge pot is hopel...

Okay first I love this color, but way too much work for an oily lidded lass like me. I had to take it back to the counter to get a tutorial on how to make it work for me (it was not going on evenly, c...

I got this in a swap, and I had high hopes for it. The packaging is great - very chic looking and keeps everything neat. However, the consistency of the cream is too dry for me to get a good applicati...