I do like this product but it is fiddly to apply. And it is pricey. I love the look but cannot be bothered with the effort hence why I would not repurchase.

I know that a lot of people have had Smudge Pots dry out on them. I do not do anything special other than cap them tightly and store them upside down and all mine last 2 years or more...none have drie...

love this color, my eyes are basically this color, I line and mascara, I line and shadow and mascara, I love this liner. Has great staying power. Seriously, I've had this a good 6 years, still using i...

I love this smudge pot! The grey looks great with my fair skin and dark eyes and stays put forever! It has a great consistency also. This is one of my favorite eyeliners.

I love using this product for smokey eyes or just gray eyes itself. It's a pretty dark gray and easier to blend than black. I don't use it as eyeliners but it work's great as an eyeshadow base.

Hw do I love thee? Let me count the ways.... This stuff is great! Goes on like a dream, stays put on my oily eyelids ALL DAY. No exaggeration. I need to get a better brush to apply it with, but I a...

I can't decide if there's something wrong with the product or my expectations on how to use it. I truly despise pencil and liquid pen liners, so I thought this would be an interesting alternative. ...

I love my gray smudge pot! I have several other colors (black, black noir, kitten) but I find that gray looks the best on me as an eyeliner. It is not harsh like black but still gives great definition...

I really liked this smudge pot. The only problem with it is that it dries out super fast!! Other than that, I love the colors they have, it stays on extremely well, & goes on good. I have also used...

The gray looks almost black in the indoor lighting, but under naturally light, the color looks very gray. I don't like how it looks in natural lighting, so i took off a lippie. Texture is better tha...