When gel liners first came out and it was all the craze, I really wanted try this! I wasn't willing to fork out money for the Bobbi Brown or MAC, so I looked around for a dupe. At that time Maybelline...

This is a Very good eyeliner very waterproof and rich glides on smooth

I think I have tried every black gel and cake liner - some fade on me in hot weather, some are a little too dry and I can't get it to go on smoothly, some not pigmented enough, some too messy to work ...