HOLY GRAIL!! I’ve been using this eyeliner for years ! It doesn’t smudge or transfer and the finish is beautiful and the blackest liner I’ve ever used

This is in my holy grail eyeliner list. I only don't like one thing: it's a bit hard to erase so you need a cotton bud to more effectively remove it from your lids. I'm lazy so I still use cotton pads...

It does last but it goes on drier than other brands so you have to go over the line a few times. Difficult to do a cat eye of the brush but I have limited options bc liquid liners either smudge or f...

my new hg finallyyyy. Pros: easy to use, smudge free for sure (even with my ten hour shifts), comes of neatly in bits - so no racoon eyes but will need oil based remover, i can even wear it between my...

This was one of my first regular liners. I know, crazy lol. It's a whopping $27. That's pricy for a liquid liner. However, I have a soft spot for Estee Lauder because my mom loves that brand. I really...

Amazing liner! It's waterproof, easy to apply, lasts all day but it's quite price. I'm sure I can find a similar product at DS. Great product nonetheless.

I'm huge fan of this eyeliner since 2008. I use it for 7 years now and hope it will never be discontinued. Mine lasts me for a year. That makes it extremely cheap compare to pencils and I can't say en...

This is a great eyeliner. I've been looking for a nice liquid eyeliner for my monolid, oily eyelids for a few years now to enhance my Asian eyes, and I have to admit that this one does the job. I got ...

I used to be truly obsessed with this and I thought I found my liquid eyeliner for life. It is so easy to out on and they way it is aids you in keeping a straight hand and making a straight line. Howe...

Really love this eyeliner. The applicator is perfectly shaped for all the precision I need, and it lasts all day. It's become a liquid liner staple