A very good pencil eyeliner, I didn't expect it to be this good. All pencil eyeliner that I've ever tried always smudge (especially the black one). Well, I do want to smudge it sometimes but I feel li...

One of the best eyeliner pencils I've used. Goes on very smooth and dark. I like the soft plastic base they have it in. I used to use Clinque Quick Eyes eyeliner but they had it in a crumbly wooden pe...

There is nothing special about this eyeliner. I bought it in black brown, and it smuged like hell. looked like that I have dirt on my eyes in the end of the day. It's just a product with a retail pric...

This is a review for the Shiseido Smoothing Eyeliner Pencil. Love this. I have tried so many eyeliners and they all tend to melt away. I wear eyeline on my waterline and this definitely lasts the long...

I guess it all depends on your skin type. I LOVE this product and it is the only eyeliner I use after trying so many. I live on a tropical island and it is hot and humid every day unless its raining. ...

just average..and i would say below average. i have to warm this up with a hair dryer to soften it up, the color is decent but could be more intense. it fades a lot, and also smudges some. the best fa...

THE worst eyeliner I have ever used. I love Shiseido's stuff, but this just doesn't cut it. Literally, FIVE minutes after I put this on, without touching it, it's already smudged/faded--just UGH.

This eyeliner does all of the following quite consistently: [ pros ] glides on smoothly, applies rich black color, one stick lasts at least 14 mo. with daily use; [ cons ] fades quickly, smudges ea...

I used this eyeliner in deep brown for a few years because I like Shiseido and was too ignorant/lazy to look for a better product. The color is nice and rich, and it goes on pretty smoothly. But it ...

I had realistic expecations: Pencil eyeliners WILL smudge. So i was looking for an almost effortless application and how much i like how my eyes look after using it. I do like how this pencil is har...