I have Fluidline (BlackTrack & Dipdown), Smolder kohl, & this (GraphBlack & Photogravure) so you can see I'm set for awhile on MAC liners. This was part of a holiday set (2015) it came w Smolder & a m...

This is okay, doesn't stay on my waterline, works fine for along my upper lashline. It's not that smooth and does skip a little when applying. It doesn't smear when used on upper lashline which is nic...

Was looking for the perfect black for my waterline. I am a contact lens user so I need something comfortable. I was using lots of other brands like urban decay, revlon, maybelline. Urban decays 24/7 i...

I was contemplating between Clinique Quickliner and this one and based on the reviews here I bought this for my waterline. But it doesn't work for me for the waterline. I've been using Bare Minerals R...

I absolutely love this product!! Before using this,I used to apply the Lakhmé eyeconic,but it used to drag a lot and was terrible on the waterline. It also didn't last for more than 6 hours. Then I ex...

You can't go wrong with this eyeliner. Great for creating a variety of looks, whether for a more dramatic nighttime look or a casual office wear look. It is long-lasting, does not smudge, and is an ...

I got this as a gag gift from a friend, her knowing full well my bad experiences with MAC products. This is no different. With UD eye potion and sealed with a powder, it still managed to make me look ...

I believe this was among one my first ever eyeliners. Its very easy and quite creamy (much less creamy than UD 24/7) but isn't too creamy to the point where it smudges easily. I've found this eyelin...

I got this with the All about Nude set. Glides on smooth over the fold on my eyes. But creases even with primer. Its jet black which i really like. I apply Benefit Push Up gel liner or UD Perversion l...

I definitely love this eyeliner and I love everything about it. It is very easy to use, it glides on the eyelid and waterline, it is long lasting, its pigmentation is good, it is retractable. I have v...