cozycot
product
Eyeliner
They're Real Push-Up Eyeliner
2.2446 reviews
Product from
B
Benefit
benefitcosmetics.com
Reviews (446)
Total review
2.2
446 reviews
Sort by
Feb 29

Genuinely the worst thing I've ever used. I hate this product so much. I'd rate it a 0 in everything. It breaks in the container, it smudges, its not precise, it breaks again on application. Literally...

Jul 9

Used it a few times before giving up. The product dries on the tip ad refuses to come out.

May 21

Worst eyeliner ever. I used drugstore eyeliner for years, then when my last tube ran out I got this pushed on me at ulta. I'm not a huge fan of benefit but I like their benetints, blushes, eyebrow pro...

Mar 7

Dry,wouldn't come out of the twister tube,wouldn't apply well,strange applicator design.

Jan 13

From today, Benefit brand is officially on my black list. I tried their mascaras and brow products, now the eyeliner and every one gave my eyes serious irritation and redness. I put the eyeliner on, l...

Jul 1

I really loved the concept of this eyeliner. The problem is that the product would come up a little bit, but not enough to make it smoothly across my lid. If I pushed up more product, it would break o...

May 15

Don’t like this at all

Mar 31

I was sold to this product when I first saw the advertising.... a super black, matte gel liner in a pen format? GOSH, I HAD TO HAVE IT! Without even swatching it in the store, I took it straight to t...

Mar 1

I really wanted to like this liner! I had a bit of an eyeliner disaster on the way to work one day so picked this up as I fancied trying it to fix what I had going on at the time. I found that the pus...

Feb 22

What an awful eyeliner! Awful is an understatement. Can't believe I wasted my hard earned money on this. I'll stick to my drugstore ones. Every time you use it, you have to keep twisting it. It takes ...

...