cozycot
product
Eyeliner
They're Real Push-Up Eyeliner
2.2446 reviews
Product from
B
Benefit
benefitcosmetics.com
Reviews (446)
Total review
2.2
446 reviews
Sort by
Feb 29, 2020

Genuinely the worst thing I've ever used. I hate this product so much. I'd rate it a 0 in everything. It breaks in the container, it smudges, its not precise, it breaks again on application. Literally...

Jul 9, 2019

Used it a few times before giving up. The product dries on the tip ad refuses to come out.

May 21, 2019

Worst eyeliner ever. I used drugstore eyeliner for years, then when my last tube ran out I got this pushed on me at ulta. I'm not a huge fan of benefit but I like their benetints, blushes, eyebrow pro...

Mar 7, 2019

Dry,wouldn't come out of the twister tube,wouldn't apply well,strange applicator design.

Jan 13, 2019

From today, Benefit brand is officially on my black list. I tried their mascaras and brow products, now the eyeliner and every one gave my eyes serious irritation and redness. I put the eyeliner on, l...

Jul 1, 2018

I really loved the concept of this eyeliner. The problem is that the product would come up a little bit, but not enough to make it smoothly across my lid. If I pushed up more product, it would break o...

May 15, 2018

Don’t like this at all

Mar 31, 2018

I was sold to this product when I first saw the advertising.... a super black, matte gel liner in a pen format? GOSH, I HAD TO HAVE IT! Without even swatching it in the store, I took it straight to t...

Mar 1, 2018

I really wanted to like this liner! I had a bit of an eyeliner disaster on the way to work one day so picked this up as I fancied trying it to fix what I had going on at the time. I found that the pus...

Feb 22, 2018

What an awful eyeliner! Awful is an understatement. Can't believe I wasted my hard earned money on this. I'll stick to my drugstore ones. Every time you use it, you have to keep twisting it. It takes ...

...