Well I *would* buy this again -- but I think it's been discontinued! I loved this eyeliner. I loved that I got both black and brown shades in one compact. I found the cake formula easy to apply and b...

OMG!!!!!! I am so upset that they discontinued this product! This was the absolute BEST eyeliner ever! I swear I want to boycott Benefit. It was so awesome that I could use a damp brush and get a nic...

UGGHHHH! They discontinued this, probably because it lasts FOREVER i have had mine a couple years and have not needed to replace it until I went to the store and it was DISCONTINUED I hate when this h...

I bought this to use as a replacement for traditional liquid eyeliner and was a little peeved that it wasn't a whole black cake, rather a 50/50 split of black and brown- I was very wrong to be annoyed...

Outstanding product. Takes a little bit of practice to get used to when you're used to using pencil or liquid liner but is well worth it. Superbly versatile when applied with a quality angle brush an...

Don't use this much but I do like it. It's a pain in the butt to add water but it goes on nicely and stays a long time. Use with the Benefit Get Bent brush and its awesome!

Really nice and easy to use. I use a flat slanted brush (hmm does it have a special name? Its a Ruby&Millie one) and just wet the brush, get some of the colour onto it then literally touch it agains...

first off this is so big that i dont think i'll ever run out of it! so i put that I wont re-purchase :P This liner is great! I wish it was waterproof but it has amazing staying power none the less. I ...

It seems as if Benefit is going to discontinue this product (I purchased mine from the buh-buys section of their website), and I am kind of bummed. Anyway, this product comes in a mirrored compact wit...

I love this eyeliner. First of all, I love the mixing process, I guess I just find it fun. For me, application is a breeze. I've used angled brushes, the Get Bent brush, and the teeny tiny liner bru...