I have this in softsmudge brown and I'm so disappointed to hear that it's been discontinued since I've used this for years and it's always worked well for me. Some of the things I loved about it were ...

Blackcoffee - try Dior's Waterproof liner in Intense Brown. It's got everything you are looking for.

This eyeliner is pretty good. I have it in the color soft smudge brown. The color is great for my brown eyes, but it's hard to apply it in a straight line, as it drags across my lid. I would like it b...

This eyeliner I actually got free with another Estée Lauder purchase but it's quite good so it gets a mini review- not hard, but not so soft that it smudges everywhere. Average eyeliner, I believe the...

I am on a never-ending lookout for an eyeliner for my waterline, that does not smudge and bleed throughout the day, all while looking natural. And I've found that time after time, I've come back to Es...

Even though it transfers slightly from my oily lids, I'm giving this pencil a 4. I have it in a lovely blue, almost navy colour. The width of the pencil is great - not so fine that you have to go ov...

I disagree with others who say this pencil is hard. I have this in 02 Soft Smudge Brown, and it's very creamy and soft. The one downside is that it is not as long wearing as other pencil eyeliners I'v...

I got this as a bonus when I went in to buy their mascara that I like. So far I have found it good; I don't think it's the best pencil I have ever used but I wouldn't say it's the worst either. Howeve...

Different from other reviews, I love this eyeliner. Yes, it's not the softest liner, but I like the harder ones better than the super soft ones. Mine has an amazing color-payoff, and if you work past,...

ARGGG ESTEE LAUDER YOU HURT... No, really, This stuff is way too tough to get onto my waterline. The only way I can see myself liking this if I were to use this gently on my lower lash line and smok...