I'm reviewing this under the color Brown. Even though I have black eyes/black hair, I find that it's a great eyeliner for a subtle every day look. I prefer it over my black gel liner (not Shiseido). A...

I'm a pretty big Shiseido fan, but was pretty disappointed with this product. While it isn't dry, the texture could be a lot more smooth and creamier, and the brush that comes with the eyeliner is rub...

I am so disappointed with this eyeliner which I have in black shade.I can't use it for cat-eye because it smudges!! And generally I wouldn't recommend creamy eyeliners to anyone who want to create a c...

I'm never going back to regular pencil eyeliners again! This is my first cream liner; I used to use liquid liner before this product and I'm very happy I switched on a whim. I'm not sure why the oth...

I was disappointed by this, I found it really difficult to use as it was so dry. The packaging was really nice and the little brush very handy but the texture was just terrible, really difficult to wo...

I have this in black. Hm. I have three other cream eyeliners and although this one was more expensive than the rest of them combined I think I like it the least. Some people might like this but the fa...

This is the eyeliner used on all the women (maybe even the men? I dunno) in the Star Trek XI movie, including Zoe Saldana who played Uhura, if anyone cares (I do). Good stuff. Set phasers to stunning!...

This is my favorite eyeliner ever! I've had mine (in black) for three years now, and I finally decided to throw it away, because it's getting dry. However, it lasted me a really long time, especially ...

This is the first cream eyeliner I've tried; I used to use a Revlon liquid. I initially found the consistency a fraction dry, but now that I'm used to it, it's not a problem. I use it to line and ti...

I have EXTREMELY oily eyelids and so most liners (pencil, liquid, gel) always end up smudging and unfortunately, this smudged a fair bit too. This was my first gel liner and so I do have a soft spot f...