This is a good pencil for a very specific look - the smokey eye. It will smudge and run into undereye lines if you don't pre-smudge it, and you'll need to use a fan brush to sweep away any black speck...

The color and texture is ok, but the lasting !!!! I wore it twice and at the end of the morning it simply disappeared, even though i put on some base and powder on my lids. Not very good, unless you j...

I agree with all the comments about how terrible this is as an eyeliner. It's too hard, smudges, falls off, and isn't true black! However, like one other reviewer I started using it as a brow pencil. ...

Wow, I am shocked to see all the hate on Black Moon by NARS! This is hands-down my favorite and most required makeup product. I keep three or four of these on hand at all times so there is one in my p...

i really detest this eyeliner. huge waste of cash. it is really poorly pigmented & is very hard. i use this in my brows now b/c i didnt want it to be a big fail. does the job but wouldnt re-purchase.

This is a decent eyeliner -- and I will say that it lasted on my waterline; it took makeup remover to get it off. For the price, though, I may not buy this again, as I have found drugstore variety eye...

I'm not sure why there was so much haterade on this product- I use this everyday and it works like a charm. If the point is too sharp- just give it a quick press against something flat and wah-lah it...

Waste of money. It makes me look like a zombie/vampire/raccoon hybrid. I mean, it's not terrible, but it looks too thick on me by the end of the day. The packaging is just like any other pencil liner....

Not worth the money. Very hard pencil, very little color pay off. It actually rubbed off the color I had beneath. HG is LM Extreme Black, ds HG is L'Oreal Carbon Black kohl. Don't waste your money on ...

This has got to be the absolute worst eyeliner I have ever used or purchased. It seemed to work really well when the MA applied it but at home it is a nightmare to work with. It takes a lot of force t...