This is my all-time favourite eye pencil! I find hard eye pencils much better that soft ones. Use it for perfect eye make up. It does not smudge unless you want it to for smokey eyes ;)

I used to wear this years and years ago. I just recently went back to it recently because I needed something to line the waterline. This does seem to work well, but it does smudge. I will continue ...

This has been my HG eyeliner for over a decade. Recently though my local estee lauder stopped stocking this one and replaced it with the "double wear" so I'm using that right now. I've tried various c...

AAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH i love this eyelinerrrrr! if you have oily lids or want to do something sharp and precise then go find another eyeline cause this is not it... but if you love a rich, deep, BLAC...

This is a nice product and I don't mean to bash on it or anything. I got this as a gift and it does the job just fine. It makes a pretty precise line and smudges and blends well. The only thing is tha...

My estee lauder lady gave me this for free. I thought cool! Well at first it looked great on for nights. it was very very black and made my eyes pop. Well I noticed at the end of the night I had dark ...

For me this shows up as a good black and if i smudge it it could pass as grey if i wanted it too. One of the best eyeliner's I've tried. Doesn't irritate me and goes on smoothly without wearing away. ...

my friend got me this product on my birthday, and I was pretty excited 2 try it coz I have super oily lids & all eyeliners tend to smudge and smear on me. this eyeliner is kinda dry and not soft 2 app...

I have been using this eyeliner off and on for years. I thought it was normal to look like a raccoon by lunchtime. It is easy to apply, but clearly not looking too great on me. I recently tried L'Orea...

This product is just okay. I have a problem with eyeliners smudging and fading. While I expected this one to smudge in a sexy smokey way, it faded way too much and made a big mess under my eyes, in a ...