cozycot
Product image not available
Eyeliner
Eye Defining Pencil in #15 Softsmudge Brown
2.918 reviews
Product from
EL
Estee Lauder
esteelauder.com
Reviews (18)
Total review
2.9
18 reviews
5
1
4
5
3
3
2
6
1
3
Sort by
Apr 18

If anyone has this pencil that you are not happy with, don't use it any more but still have it...Please contact me if you would like to get rid of it. It works well for me and I can send you a SASE t...

Nov 16

pardon my saying but this product sucks. It tugs at the eye, doesn't leave a vibrant brown color. it's just blegh. i only use it when it comes free in a kit, and if its the only brown liner I can gra...

Jun 5

Long lasting, but too rough and flaky on the skin. It tugs at the eye and must layer it to see the color.

Jan 10

The pencil smudges and by the end of the day, it's melted off my face. Not pretty.

Sep 28

As good as any standard pencil, although not the long-wearing kind. Soft, smudgeable, and most of all, non-irritating to my sensitive eyes. Would not recommend for lower lash line. Since I line my ...

Sep 18

I used to swear by this but then I found one at Avon that lasted a lot longer. This color is great for blue eyes and I really enjoyed this for about 8 years so it must be pretty good. I just now fou...

May 15

Absolute waste of money. This pencil doesn't smudge-it SMEARS.

Feb 14

I got the Softsmudge Brown Pencils as a GWP so it doesn't have the smudger tip, it is a small size. The texture is rather soft and easily blendable, but... The color has a bit too much "reddish" tints...

Feb 5

Nothing special. If you want a basic brown pencil liner, go to the drugstore before buying this. I received it as a GWP, so there was no real cost to me, and I still don't use it. It sits at the botto...

May 7

I guess I'm the minority liking this pencil. I got it as a GWP years ago and I still use it. It smudges nicely and stays put well. The brown goes with my hazel eyes.