My all time favourite eye liner. It goes on smooth and I personally use it to make top wings on my lids with a small angled brush and a few strokes. I must warn though that it goes on heavily so a lit...

This is very black and smooth only problem is it doesnt really last the entire night and if it does, most likely it will smudge where your low lashes are.... i would recommend a gel eyeliner for the l...

Looks as if this is discontinued. Just bought 3 on Amazon. The only eyeliner color and type i lovefor waterline. Please Stila bring it back.

<b><i>Product</i></b> - Matte battleship grey, not as dark as charcoal grey on me (AAB/NC25). Creamy, soft, smooth texture, easy to work with. Excellent pigmentation and staying power - and I have w...

I really like this eyeliner for my waterline it doesn't smudge even though it's so creamy! Very easy to apply and it lasts! So overal it's a good buy I would definately repurchase!:)

This is my go to everyday eyeliner. It's a deep gray that gives a softer look than straight up black. I don't like how it smudges and runs, but I find when I set it with powder, it's better. I think i...

I don't know about the others, but I really like Stila's Kajal Eye Liner in Smokey Quartz! I use this nearly everyday, and I haven't had a problem with it. The liner stays on all day, aLLLLLLLLLL thro...

I like the color, because it is not a super-dramatic dark black, yet is still impactful. But I have the same complaint on this one as the Tiger's Eye -- it's too soft and doesn't stay sharp for long, ...

I think this eyeliner is a great, slightly less intense alternative to black liner. I've used it on my top lashline a couple times so far and it doesn't smudge on me, but gives a soft but defined look...

Stila Kajal Eye Liner is the only eye liner I use. Ever. Smokey Quartz is my go-to color - even though I have dark features, I feel like black is a little too harsh most of the time and SQ is just t...