cozycot
product
Eyeliner
BADgal
3.1252 reviews
Product from
B
Benefit
benefitcosmetics.com
Reviews (252)
Total review
3.1
252 reviews
Sort by
Mar 26, 2024

They should have named it BAD LINER

Jul 11, 2015

This Bad Gal liner is sub-par in my opinion. The deep black color ends up a dark grayish black on the lids. It's almost patchy to apply and doesn't smoothly glide on as other liners I have do. It's qu...

Mar 22, 2014

I got this in a Benefit set with the "BADgal" mascara at Sephora. I use black eye liner almost daily to tightline or define my upper lashes; and having smaller, hooded eyes also means most of them smu...

Dec 13, 2013

I am in sweet love with this eye pencil. It doesn't melt on me!

Oct 15, 2013

I have purchased other eyeliners from Benefit before and they were decent. This one however was by far the worst eyeliner I have ever purchased, not to mention the price was moderate. I have purchased...

Oct 19, 2012

I like this eyeliner when I am looking for a darker more dramatic look. It does smudge easily so I first put on my daily eye liner (Mabelline unstoppable) then I take this badGal liner in darkest blac...

Aug 20, 2012

The eyeliner keeps breaking so first of all it doesn't last even for 2 weeks. It doesn't last for long once applied. It gets smudged. I didn't have time and energy to go and return. This one product h...

Mar 20, 2012

I love it!big fat chunky pencil which gives amazingly sexy smokey eyes albeit in need of regular top ups. The pencil lasts quite a while too, although I would definitely buy it online and save a few ...

Mar 11, 2012

Too fat to really be used as an eyeliner (unless you want to keep sharpening and wasting product). Good for a smokey eye, but it still smudges and has almost no staying power. This pencil is also def...

Feb 21, 2012

Zero staying power and very little pigment. Don't bother...

...