It looks decent on, like most mascaras, but it smudges so quickly. End up getting visible smudges under my eyes after only a couple of hours, no matter what I do. Had to give it away.
I just got this mascara, and I like it. It looks natural on my eye lids, makes them look longer. It doesn't add much volume, but that's ok. It stays on pretty well, although it is not 100% waterproof...
It's not MAGNIFICENT in any way, but overall good in my opinion. A bit difficult to remove, which can be both positive and negative.