This is the best liner I've found, particularly the ice black color which is more of a metallic dark taupe. I use it for tightlining as well as above my lashes. Smudgeable until it dries, then it does...
I had great expectations for this based on the reviews here, hoping it was different enough from the original No. 5, but boooo, this smells exactly like MIL's stale cigarette/ No. 5 infused mink coat....
These are worth the extra $ for a little luxury, and I only use one where I might use 2 cheaper ones, plus these are never scratchy or linty.
Second everything that's been said, I love this, so glad I was able to get a tin from a lovely swapper.
I am hooked on this and other fragrances of L'Occitane soap now, they are so nice and very long-lasting, making them actually very good value for the $$. Rather than trying to get the effect of high ...
I find this is a bit over-rated, but I'm a sucker for hype and bought it anyway...I'm a nurse and wash my hands a million times a day,and after trying everything I like Glysomed cream the best.
I have this in Honey and like it but for the $$ it's not that special, texture is too dry and I probably should have been more adventurous with my color choice.
It irritates me that so many people reviewed this as a concealer (under eyes, on blemishes), when it is clearly marketed as a non-shimmery highlighter for lines, inner/outer eye corners, liplines, low...
Sorry, but this just has not ever worked for me, somehow makes my thin lips look more so, and ends up looking too dark and obvious on me (PPP).
