I have only used Eyes Etude Play 101 house pencil in #8 Its a fantastic bargain alternative to "Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes™ Inner Rim Liner". Just like Tarte, it brightens the inner rim of my eyes...

For the color pink #1, the lightest pink. Not sure if I would buy this again. It would highly depend if I found another tint that was with in the same color, price range and quality. Don't let this ...