This is my HG eyeliner! I originally hunted it down on eBay three years ago, before it was a part of BB's permanent collection, when it had only been offered as a NM GWP. I paid close to $50 dollars...
This palette is hit or miss IMO. I really never use three of the shades, but I adore the PSand color and use it daily as a wash. It looks great with my blue eyes. Just a little touch that looks goo...