Its very black, so it gets a star. Doesn't clump, but it does flake all over your face. Doesn't build up or lengthen, and the formula is quite dry. All in all, I was very disappointed. I was expecting...

I've used a few oil-based cleansers before trying this one - Shu Uemura and Origins are the ones we all recognise. The Origins one is good, but not great. The Shu Uemura is good but expensive. The Shi...