Seriously the WORST eye liner i have used! Claims to be waterproof ( it is not) i was so angry after buying this, its not cheap and basically doesn't do anything it claims to do. I looked like a panda...

I searched the best and worst top 10 lip plumpers and this was no 9 with 8.7/10 and 70% would repurchase ( according to total beauty.com).No 10 was a Smashbox one. I rushed out to buy it as a 40yr old...